The objective of the legal analysis in this paper is to determine whether the legal and legitimate basis for humanitarian intervention exists under international law and if so, when and under whose authority. To protect state sovereignty is it possible to resist evil. Successful humanitarian interventions and war in syria. I will try, to the extent it is possible and desirable, to leave the issue of legitimacy. The present article addresses the concepts of violation of state sovereignty. The dilemma of humanitarian intervention council on. Certain crimes must be prosecuted, whether states like it or not. Pdf interventions on the state of sovereignty at the border. Humanitarian intervention is not a use of force, and while it may violate another states sovereignty can invoke the justification of necessity. Issued by the international development research centre. Humanitarian intervention is generally understood to be the transboundary use of military force in order to halt or avert largescale and grave human suffering, and is a subject that has attracted much scholarly attention in recent decades. Classical approach puts emphasize on the principle of sovereignty when. Sovereignty vs humanitarian intervention politics essay. It examines whether human rights explicitly adhere to the sphere of internala affairs of states or to the sphere of international interest of global society.
The problem of humanitarian intervention globalization101. Most of the discourse has been about legal issues, as outlined above. Humanitarian intervention, the responsibility to protect. The legal foundations of foreign intervention, 27 cornell international law journal 1994, 20339. Human rights norms, state sovereignty, and humanitarian.
Nonetheless, the question of when, if ever, outside parties can legitimately intervene in a sovereign state to address massive suffering of that states population, is a highly contentious one. Humanitarian intervention, the responsibility to protect, and. Humanitarian intervention in a sovereign state by tom bamforth, development consultant july 2006 for many aid workers, their formative professional experiences include stints in darfur, bosnia, kosovo, east timor or afghanistan. The case against military intervention has to be seen in this light and against the. The principle of nonintervention has always been considered as the ruling canon of state sovereignty.
Lecture 12 humanitarian intervention 1 there are international organizations that have codified standards for common humanity. Have the norms of sovereignty altered to provide for. Introduction the events of the arab spring and subsequent developments in libya and egypt raise profound questions regarding the tension between international humanitarian intervention and state sovereignty in the context of geopolitics. Each states right to stability and sovereignty must be balanced against the obligation of foreign actors to intervene in the event of severe human. International develop ment research centre for iciss, 2001, 410 pp. The united nations in an evolving world orderphiladelphia. Violating national sovereignty was a serious infringement of.
Taylor seybolts thoroughly documented and rigorously argued cases provide speci. Human rights quarterly, volume 37, number 2, may 2015, pp. The united nations, formed in the aftermath of world war ii to promote peace and stability, recognizes the importance of sovereignty, especially for. The changing character of sovereignty the principle of state sovereignty was the traditional legal order of international relations. Gareth evans is the current president of the international crisis group icg and former australian foreign minister 198896. Humanitarian intervention essay sample new york essays. Sovereignty versus humanitarian intervention sage journals. Until very recently, the debate over humanitarian intervention has been premised on the existence of a particular and widespread view of state sovereignty which insulates a state from intervention and which should only be violated in the most extreme circumstances, if even then. Some scholars deny the right of another state to intervene even on grounds of humanitarian reasons because they believe that to intervene means to violate the sovereignty of a state. The dilemma of armed humanitarian intervention dr georges labaki professor, notre dame university lebanon the concept of state sovereignty has been the underlying principle of international relations since the treaty of westphalia in 1648. Military intervention for the stated purpose of helping the local population to survive the predations of armed and dangerous men was not a flash in the pan, as shown. International commission on intervention and state sovereignty 2001, to symposium on humanitarian intervention, university of wisconsinmadison, mar. Humanitarian intervention has been defined as a states use of military force against another state, with publicly stating its goal is to end human rights violations in that state. Warfare destroys lives, property, infrastructure, and environment in waysand to an extentthat economic and diplomatic pressures do not.
It defends the emergence of a right of humanitarian intervention and argues that state sovereignty is not incompatible with humanitarian intervention. This report is about the socalled right of humanitarian intervention. International commission on intervention and state sovereignty. On this broader understanding, humanitarian intervention should be. The author states that had the humanitarian intervention been accepted by law, it would provide limitless options to use military power in cases. Humanitarian intervention and the protection of civilian populations abstract the author interrogates the critical question of whether forcible humanitarian intervention be legitimised in spite of clear contradiction to the classical norms of interstate relations. State sovereignty and international intervention johns hopkins university press, baltimore, 1995, pp. In the pages to follow, an exploration of the legal status of humanitarian intervention is thus attempted. Humanitarian relief is the provision of nonmilitary aid such as water, food, medicine, clothing, blankets etc.
Uncertainty arises as to whether there are any moral obligation for humanitarian intervention and the concerning justifications of the violation of state sovereignty. The concept of state sovereignty has since long, been ingrained in the international sphere. International commission on intervention and state sovereignty iciss report in 2001, the responsibility to protect, commissioned by canadian government r2p argues that if states failed to protect human rights of its citizens, then international community will respond and the sovereignty of the state is temporarily suspended. M ayoob humanitarian intervention and state sovereignty.
For humanitarian intervention to become possible, members of the security council, including most of its permanent members, must adopt or accede to a common story about the character of the conflict and its resultant human rights violations an intentional causal story with clear victims and identifiable and intentional perpetrators. Mohammed ayoob, james madison college, michigan state university. Sovereignty eclipsed the legitimacy of humanitarian. What makes humanitarian military interventions effective. Intervention, libya, and the future of sovereignty international law and the governments that bring it into being are the process of redefining the definition of sovereignty annemarie slaughter.
An indian perspective by kapil kak introduction the decade of the 1990s, in the immediate aftermath of the cold war, was characterized by frequent military interventions for human protection in somalia 199295,haiti 1994, rwanda 1994, east timor 1999 and kosovo 1999 to name a few. Humanitarian intervention has been defined as the justifiable use of force for the purpose of protecting the inhabitants of another state from treatment so arbitrary and persistently abusive as to exceed the limits within which the sovereign is presumed to act with reason and justice. State sovereignty and intervention are seen as inherently contradictory concepts. Humanitarian intervention responsibility to protect. Humanitarian intervention has been the subject of much recent contro versy. The development of the international organization have led to reducing the authority of the principle of states sovereignty, since the area in which the international.
Third world perspectives on humanitarian intervention and. This definition may be too narrow as it precludes nonmilitary forms of intervention such as humanitarian aid and international sanctions. Pdf humanitarian intervention and state sovereignty. Humanitarian intervention and state responsibility jan. Each state recognizes no higher authority than itself in the regulation of affairs in its own territory, which is a definition of sovereignty. The problem of humanitarian intervention courts of international law represent one way in which the international community has decided to limit the sovereignty of states. Reconciling humanitarian intervention and sovereignty. Humanitarian intervention and the distribution of sovereignty in international law patrick macklem september 2006 draft abstract legal debates about humanitarian intervention military intervention by one or more states to curb gross human rights violations occurring in another state tend to assume that its legitimacy. Nonetheless, the case against violent intervention cannot be dismissed merely by noting that sovereignty is not absolute.
The brief report should include an elucidation of the balance between state sovereignty and the possibilities for the international community to intervene in situations where massive violations of human rights take place, threatening. According to held, its contemporary meaning had not already been defined in the westphalian treaties, but it is rather a construction of the 18 th and 19 th centuries, when territorial sovereignty, the formal equality of states, nonintervention in the domestic affairs of other recognized states, and state consent as the basis of. The underlying idea is that, states must refrain from intervening in the matters of other states, to the greatest possible extent. Humanitarian intervention in state practice after 1945. The issue of humanitarian intervention has become increasingly prominent in worldwide debates regarding its role in ethics and legitimacy in international relations. This form of sovereignty can be compromised through intervention as well as through invitation, when a state voluntarily subjects internal authority structures to external constraints. The rule of law in an incoherent world ian hurd t he concept of humanitarian intervention has evolved as a subset of the laws governing the use of force and has very quickly come to occupy an institutional position alongside selfdefense and security council authorization as a legal and legitimate reason for. The united nations security council and humanitarian. Interventions on the state of sovereignty at the border article pdf available in political geography 59. Such intervention is prohibited by the united nations charter art. Critics often observe that humanitarian intervention poses chal lenges to state sovereignty and that the principle of nonintervention is well.
International commission on intervention and state sovereignty the responsibility to protect report of the international commission on intervention and state sovereignty issued also in french under title. One of these international documents is the 2001 report responsibility to protect produced by the international commission on intervention and state sovereignty iciss. Humanitarian intervention and the distribution of sovereignty in international law patrick macklem abstract legal debates about humanitarian intervention military intervention by one or more states to curb gross human rights violations occurring in another state tend to assume that its legitimacy is irrelevant to its legality. Intervention, libya, and the future of sovereignty the. In international law, the concept of intervention is tied to the notion interference and is when a state intervenes in the internal affairs of another state, in violation of the latters sovereignty. Responsibility to protect, humanitarian intervention and. International commission on intervention and state sovereignty iciss, which emphasized the central role of the security council in issues of humanitarian intervention, concluded, it is unconscionable that one. The history of humanitarian intervention in theory and. Former british foreign minister robin cook discusses the high level panel on threats, challenges and changes recommendation of humanitarian intervention and highlights the dilemma between the right to protection from outside intervention on the one hand and the right to override state sovereignty when a government oppresses its people on the. Principle of the states sovereignty and the phenomenon of. M ayoob humanitarian intervention and state sovereignty the international from sis 619 at american university. Reconciling humanitarian intervention and sovereignty 1. Military interventions in iraqi kurdistan in 1991 and somalia in 1992 marked the emergence of a phenomenon that had previously received little practical or analytical attention. This paper will address the tension between state sovereignty and humanitarian intervention.
1428 1314 1382 134 1484 1475 136 110 210 1216 88 931 1155 651 1234 1091 1482 11 1190 267 842 1262 416 367 546 70 1370 219 953 469 743 473 1475 188 939 1261 983 1018 923 48 1380 1406 933 385 1285 656 1040